BrokerStaffer vs the alternatives
Data tools tell you who to call. Software helps you call. Services call, text or advertise for you. Here’s how each one compares on who does the work, what you pay for, and whether the leads are yours.
Pick an alternative to compare
Eleven things that decide what you actually get. Pick a company to see where BrokerStaffer stands out.
VSSame price. Your leads aren’t shared.
RealCruiters charges $150 per lead, but those leads can go to up to two other teams. Every BrokerStaffer lead replied to an email about your brokerage, so it’s yours alone.
Read the full comparison →VSPay for agents open to joining you, not a monthly fee.
Texting Betty texts your list and books calls for a flat monthly fee. We email the agents you choose at their personal inbox, and you pay only for results.
Read the full comparison →VSNo ad spend. No 16-week program. Pay per result.
Agent Attraction runs Meta ads into a recruiting funnel, with daily ad spend on top of their fee. We go straight to the agents you pick.
Read the full comparison →VSCold calls get screened. Personal email gets read.
SmartSetter’s team calls agents and books appointments. We reach them in the inbox they check and follow up until they’re ready.
Read the full comparison →VSRecruiting at scale, not one call at a time.
Peterson’s team cold-calls agents and sets appointments. We reach every agent on your list at once and follow up until they’re ready.
Read the full comparison →VSTools every month, or pay only when an agent is open to a conversation about joining you.
Brokers Recruiter gives you agent search, calling, texting and email from $199 a month. You still make the calls and send the messages.
Read the full comparison →VSBrokerKit gives you a recruiting system. We give you results.
BrokerKit organizes your calls, texts, emails and drips. It still needs someone on your team to run it every day.
Read the full comparison →VSCourted shows you the agents. We start the conversations.
Courted gives you agent production, a recruiting pipeline and AI drafting help. We plug into it and do the outreach your team doesn’t have time for.
Read the full comparison →VSRelitix tells you who might move. We get them talking.
Relitix scores agents on production and how likely they are to leave. We take that list and turn it into conversations.
Read the full comparison →VSMarketView shows you the top producers. We get them to reply.
MarketView ranks agents by sales and tracks office and firm activity. We reach the ones you want in their personal inbox.
Read the full comparison →VSBrokerMetrics tracks who’s moving. We help them move to you.
Lone Wolf BrokerMetrics shows agent movement and production across your market. We turn that insight into conversations.
Read the full comparison →Keep it. We plug into it.
Data tools tell you which agents to go after. We pull your target list from the one you already pay for, then do the outreach and follow-up your team doesn’t have time for.
Courted shows you the agents. We start the conversations.
Relitix tells you who might move. We get them talking.
MarketView shows you the top producers. We get them to reply.
BrokerMetrics tracks who’s moving. We help them move to you.
Every comparison, in full
Questions brokers ask
What is the best alternative to an agent recruiting service with a monthly fee?
A pay-per-result service. With BrokerStaffer there is no monthly fee: you pay $150 per interested agent, $250 per interested agent who matches your production filters, $500 per call that shows up, or $5,000 per salaried hire.
Is BrokerStaffer a recruiting CRM like BrokerKit or Brokers Recruiter?
No. Those are software your team runs every day. BrokerStaffer does the outreach and follow-up for you, and every client also gets a recruiting CRM that syncs with Follow Up Boss.
Do I need to cancel Courted, Relitix, MarketView or BrokerMetrics?
No. We pull your target list from the data tool you already use, or from our own agent database if you don’t have one.
How is BrokerStaffer different from calling and texting services?
We only use personal email, sent by our team. Agents reply when they’re ready, and we follow up until they are. Across our campaigns, 5 to 10% of the agents we email reply.
Are BrokerStaffer leads shared with other brokerages?
No. Each agent replied to an email about your brokerage and your offer, so every interested agent is yours alone.
Only pay for agents ready to talk about joining you.
No retainer, no monthly fee.